2yrs
Matthews (21): 144gms, ES 15:30 (A-), 2.49p60, 2.34p160, 51.3cf% (+0.7), 52.6xgf% (+2.2) / PP 2:19, 6.29p60, 4.49p160
Kucherov (25): 154gms, ES 16:11 (A-), 2.67p60, 2.05p160, 53.6cf% (+3.0), 53.2xgf% (+2.2) / PP 3:26, 7.63p60, 5.55p160
Last year only
Matthews (20): 62gms, ES 15:57 (A+), 3.03p60, 2.71p160, 50.9cf% (+0.4), 53.3xgf% (+2.9) / PP 2:09, 5.89p60, 3.63p160
Kucherov (24): 80gms, ES 16:18 (A-), 2.91p60, 2.24p160, 52.8cf% (+0.8), 52.0xgf% (-1.3) / PP 3:31, 7.82p60, 5.21p160
IMO Matthews is flat out better, by a healthy margin, and then you can add in age and position on top of that to widen that gap further.