Idk zeke, it makes so much more sense to just believe that Babcock has no idea what he is doing...that Shanahan and Lucky Lou are idiots as well for letting him coach the team.
One the one hand, it's unrealistic to think that Babcock has no clue what he's doing, or that he's an awful coach.
On the other hand, it's equally unrealistic to think that Babcock isn't a human being that, like the rest of us, has his own blind spots and makes mistakes from time to time.
It's also not like what's happening right now is unprecedented. One of the big criticisms late in Babcock's tenure with Detroit is that he'd fall in love with hard-working plugs, and remain unshakingly loyal to them regardless of whether or not their actual play on the ice showed that they merited the ice-time, or even the spot in the lineup they were being given.
In Detroit, those guys were Drew Miller, Dan Cleary & Luke Glendening.
In Toronto, it's Leo Komarov, Roman Polak, Zach Hyman & Matt Martin. And at some point, if the team doesn't start playing better and winning, and/or if Babcock doesn't decide to decrease the usage of his favourite toys himself, it's going to be the job of someone above Babcock on the chain of command to do something about this.