The criticism of matthews reminds me of the criticism yzerman got when he was a youngster... no heart they said.
Matthews will be fine....he is a stud and will lead the leafs to the cup soon.
Even though anderson shit the bed on a few goals, he has been doing it all year and last year too. Like i mentioned earlier, anderson was the direct cause of 2 losses against washington in last years playoffs. But anderson can be brilliant too. Goalies are a weird bunch and they seem to hit thwir stride later on in their careers. I wouldnt get rid of anderson (he is way better than reimer ever was or ever will be).
I think shannahan and lou have to take a portion of the blame,
Babcock for all his stubbornness, (and fixation on giving particular guys icetime because they are gudpros) only has the players that lou and shanny are able to deliver.
I dont believe for one second that the leafs hierarchy really believed that the team as it stands would be a rrue stanley cup contender. Otherwise they would have brought in help at the trade deadline. Pleks was nothing more than a token gesture.
As someone mentioned earlier, the pens were able to win with their defence the way it is because of their offence. I agree, and the leafs dont have the pens offensive ability, YET.
I think that this coming season, has been the time frame all along that shanny, lou, and babcock have been striving for as beginning to start investing inparts to be serious contenders.
I really think that they are going to go after tavares because with him in the stable that would help make the leafs comparable to the pens offensively.
I do believe they were hoping that gardiner would mature into a really serviceable number 2-defenceman, but it is painfully obvious that this guy has to go ... i wouldnt even keep him as a 3rd pairing dman.
As funny as it may sound, i think weber would be a great addition for the team and he would be extremely useful for at least 3 seasons. I think he would pair beautifully with reilly. Yes, there is the contract, but alot can happen in 3 or 4 years. Weber could retire or get injured and there will always be owners who will take on the contract to get a draft choice if need be.
Is weber too old and slow.... i dont know, chara is old and slow and he dominated his matchup. Oh and weber can fire the puck better than any other leaf dman on the team presently .
Finally, i would tell polak that he did a great job with his limited abilities and if he wanted to stick around as a 7th dman next season i would resign him. But the bottom pair guy i would go after would be bieksa. He can pass and skate ok. He can play defence well enough and is as tough as nails.
Reilly weber
Zaitsev dermott
Hainsy beiksa
Just a thought
Btw i think marleau played a good series and plek did too and even though the kids made mistakes, they played well too.
Disappointing ending to the series but our top 8 core maybe have a combined age average of 23 .... that is still really really young.