I really have no problem with either Tavares or Matthews getting the C. Tavares is a good captain too, and I'd say after half a season the chemistry in the dressing room should work itself out the team will know who should be the C.
Even if Tavares is the next C, it doesn't mean Matthews can't be the Leafs captain at some point in time. Tavares is 28, he has signed a 7 years deal. I presume he will retire after 7 years, at that point Matthews will be 27. Seems to be that's a good time to become C.
And I think really, at the end of the day, AM and JT don't care so much about the captaincy as the fans. It's a pretty minor issue imo.
I'm more interested in Matthew's extension. I think both sides know what Matthews will sign for with very little wiggle room (I'll be surprised if Matthews sign anything but a 8 years x $10.5M - 11M contract) ... it shouldn't be a tough negotiation.
To me, the main point is really to sign Marner to an extension. Marner had a great 2nd half, and if he does not sign this summer, and he goes on to have a PPG season, he will be worth a lot more next summer.
I hope if Matthews and Nylander both signing this summer, that would be enough initiative to get Marner to sign an extension at the same time. I presume the trio wants to play together for a long time, and the other 2 signing might lure Marner to sign something based on his value to day.
I hope we can get AM for $10.5M, Nylander for $6M and Marner for $6.5M before training camp starts. That will be VERY GOOD for us going forawrd.