Relied on luck, their pp and goalie for the majority of the year. With those two average-below average, this team is probably a leagur average one. Good news is, the pp likely won't be bad for long and there's potential for Andersen to be a top 5-10 goalie too. May push them to a top ten spot when all is said and done, but they really need to be better 5 on 5 if they have the cup on their mind. Winning the cup is often mostly luck-based but playing better 5 on 5 would certainly give them better odds. No reason why they can't... They just seem disorganized, which to me isn't really a personel issue.
I do think babcocks biggest issue is his talent evaluation. It's not a good sign when Leivo is the odd man out from this group, Zaitsev is relied upon as a top four d when the two guys on the bottom pair are imo clearly better, and Zach Hyman has a cemented spot on a top two line. But now I'm starting to wonder about him tactically too. He just hasn't gotten them to play anywhere close to organized, crisp hockey.