My churn game definitely needs help. Started last yr with Amex train (collected 170,000 MR points) plus SPG x2 plus Alaska Air Miles. Since then, I've been paralysed. No idea what to do next.
Did you close them after 6 months? And then apply again 6 months later? Doing the train with a SO makes things a hell of a lot more profitable (you can refer each other and get over double the points) but regardless there are many awesome promos available:
1. The 2 TD cards I mentioned earlier. 30,000 Aeroplan for the one card and 80,000 TD points (worth $400 if using Expedia for TD to book anything. Can also book travel any other way or get a statement credit for a lesser redemption rate) for the other. Both are slam dunks.
2. BMO world elite MasterCard has a pretty good promo right now I believe.
3. BMO air miles world elite. 3000 air miles after spending 3k in 3 months. First year free. I don't have this one but it's on my radar.
4. CIBC Aventura visa for business. 35,000 points plus $120 travel credit after spending 3k in 3 months. First year free. I used this one when I booked Japan - combined the points and the travel credit to get $450 off the already cheap flights. Very very good card here.
5. I don't know if you're in Quebec but the HSBC world elite MasterCard is a no brainer if you are. No brainer. Deal isn't great for anyone else.
6. Honourable mention: MBNA best western card. If you apply through gcr they'll give you $60. This card used to offer 60,000 points or at the very least 40,000. Keep an eye on any promos this summer. I just applied anyway for 20,000 points because it's a free card and doesn't require a minimum spend. Kind of a freebee. Points are typically worth about $0.01 each, so you'll get $200 worth of points plus $60 cash. Below my usual threshold for applying but I needed the points and no minimum spend makes it easy to take the plunge.
Those are my favourite promos right now. I simply keep them all open for six months, close them and wait for more promos. In the case of amex I just reapply six months later. Those can net me as much as $1200 each card. It will be a sad day when they completely make churning impossible for those.
My rule is that I typically look for at least a $300 value when I apply for cards. If I'm really looking, I'd accept $250. But there are usually more than enough cards out there to get the biggest rewards.