• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

2018 NHL Draft Thread

If Nashville is as smart as I think they are, they should be looking to trade Subban, if they're trading any of their dmen.
 
nah, he's been borderline top-4 at best.

Yr 1: 17:00 (#5)
Yr 2: 19:08 (#3)
Yr 3: 17:42 (#5)
Yr 4: 19:51 (#5)
Yr 5: 19:18 (#6)
Yr 6: 17:06 (#6)

Gudas Career 18:34
Polak Career 18:58
 
nah, he's been borderline top-4 at best.

Yr 1: 17:00 (#5)
Yr 2: 19:08 (#3)
Yr 3: 17:42 (#5)
Yr 4: 19:51 (#5)
Yr 5: 19:18 (#6)
Yr 6: 17:06 (#6)

Gudas Career 18:34
Polak Career 18:58

Heh

Now do 5 on 5 TOI/GP like you usually would if you liked him.
 
2012-13: 15:59 (5th)
2013-14: 16:37 (3rd)
2014-15: 16:16 (4th)
2015-16: 16:38 (4th)
2016-17: 17:19 (3rd)

2017-18: 15:10 (6th)


Exactly like I said. Top 4 every year aside from his rookie season, and last season.
 
Polak 2013-2018

P/60: .61
P1/60: .38
Rel CF: -3.65
Rel xGF: -2.38
TOIQoC: 28.41


Gudas 2013-2018

P/60: .78
P1/60: .54
Rel CF: +1.57
Rel xGF: +.86
TOIQoC: 28.83

Yeah, it's like looking in the ****ing mirror. The Athletic's take on him is better than my own as well. I'm borrowing their line when I said that Gudas is what Babcock thinks Polak is. He's a #4 quality version of Polak.

and just for fun

Zaitsev:

P/60: .74
P1/60: .50
Rel CF: -2.6
Rel xGF: -2.44
TOIQoC: 29.39

So harder competition than Gudas definitely, but significantly inferior play driving results. Even if we take a look at an aged Hainsey over the last 2 seasons:

P/60: .60
P1/60: .39
Rel CF: -2.25
Rel xGF: .23
TOIQoC: 29.46

Again harder competition, with okay results.

Fwiw, here's the Athletic article I keep mentioning

https://theathletic.com/348157/2018...he-defensive-d-men-puck-movers-and-wildcards/
 
Last edited:
2014-15

Hedman 59gms, 17:47
Carle 59gms, 17:46
Stralman 82gms, 16:53

Gudas 31gms, 16:16
Sustr 72gms, 16:08
Garrison 70gms, 16:06
Barberio 52gms, 15:55

Gudas played only 31gms, and dmen #4-7 had virtually idential icetime.


and Philly definitely thought they were getting a top-4 dman, and played him as such to start...and then paid him as much......but already by year 2 of his big deal he was relegated to bottom pair duty, and his team was finally good defensively.

borderline top-4 dman at best.
 
borderline top-4 dman at best.

and this is how you would decribe Roman Polak?

Shit, this is how I would describe Hainsey and Zaitsev at this point. So yeah, I'm proposing that we add a guy who is basically as good as our other options on the right side, who adds a physicality that we lack, and somehow manages to have better puck moving numbers than anyone on our right side last year (despite it not being the strength of his game).

and we can probably get him basically for free. Big upgrade on Polak, big upgrade on whatever it was Zaitsev was last year, and if 2nd half Hainsey is the new normal, big upgrade on Hainsey.

Ideal upgrade? No. Cheap upgrade? Yeah.

I'm open to other ideas, but you seem to not like anything potentially available that won't cost a wunderkid.
 
Gudas is an interesting, cheap option if we had cap issues. I'd aim higher though. We have the cap space to not need to cheap out this year. They have to find away to creatively spend it on the best players possible.
 
maybe, but he's still a bottom pair dman making $3.4m.

Zaitsev is a bottom pair defender making 4.5, Hainsey a bottom pairing defender making 3.

Sometimes you have to ignore labels and just try to improve your hockey club. Gudas would improve our hockey club at minimal player acquisition cost, on an affordable 2 year deal and history suggests that he can handle 2nd pairing minutes while providing solid play driving results. It's also a move that wouldn't get in the way of making a more impactful improvement. Gudas 2 yrs at 3.35 >>>> Zaitsev for 6 years at 4.5.

He would be a nasty #4-5 here who plays on the right side of the ice and while not great at it, is competent enough at breaking out of his zone (better than Polak and Hainsey at breakouts by the numbers, damn close to on par with Zaitsev). Would be a really solid linemate for Dermott, Borgman or even Gardiner.
 
Gudas is an interesting, cheap option if we had cap issues. I'd aim higher though. We have the cap space to not need to cheap out this year. They have to find away to creatively spend it on the best players possible.

I agree, I just don't know who that player is. Ryan Ellis maybe. There just aren't a lot of expensive 1 yr deals out there that a reasonable hockey trade can be made on.

Here's your list of all defenders with 1 yr left on their deal with a caphit higher than 4 million, and a select few below that cap number:

Doughty
Karlsson
Myers
Orpik
OEL
Edler
Chara
Methot
Martin
Kronwall
McDonagh
Stralman
Hjalmarsson
Coburn
MDZ
Ellis
Schmidt


So who is our get on that list?
 
Well ideally Carlsson, Doughty, Karlsson, Ellis/Subban, or OEL. Lots of high end talent out there, and if any of them move the Leafs should be all over it. And the list of "expensive" dman available could be longer than that with names like Faulk, Hamilton, Hanifin, Barrie, Spurgeon, Dumba etc. being thrown around.

As far as a depth dman like Gudas goes, I would rather Dubas use his Dubasness to get us cheaper, undervalued depth options with higher upside like they did in Vegas, rather than waste cap space on a player that we don't want to get a decent 4/5. And that may even be someone already in house like a Holl.
 
Last edited:
If Zaitsev plays more like rookie Zaits then last season's version, I think he can capably hold down the #4 spot. Or at least we have to hope that happens, because otherwise his contract becomes quite the boat anchor.

Did we ever sign that Ozighanov officially too?

I do think we will need to add a d-man though, and I'm not really sure who my top options would be.
 
Zaitsev is a bottom pair defender making 4.5, Hainsey a bottom pairing defender making 3.

Sometimes you have to ignore labels and just try to improve your hockey club. Gudas would improve our hockey club at minimal player acquisition cost, on an affordable 2 year deal and history suggests that he can handle 2nd pairing minutes while providing solid play driving results. It's also a move that wouldn't get in the way of making a more impactful improvement. Gudas 2 yrs at 3.35 >>>> Zaitsev for 6 years at 4.5.

He would be a nasty #4-5 here who plays on the right side of the ice and while not great at it, is competent enough at breaking out of his zone (better than Polak and Hainsey at breakouts by the numbers, damn close to on par with Zaitsev). Would be a really solid linemate for Dermott, Borgman or even Gardiner.

yeah, pass on the bottom pair defender.
 
on John Carlson's "great playoff run"


Orlov: ES 21:50 (A++), 1.08p60, +5.0cfrel, +5.0xgfrel / PP 1:09, 0.00p60 / PK 1:30
Niskanen: ES 22:07 (A++), 1.06p60, +2.1cfrel, +4.0xgfrel / PP 0:25, 0.00p60 / PK 3:05

Carlson: ES 20:21 (B+), 0.61p60, +0.4cfrel, -0.0xgfrel / PP 3:30, 8.99p60 / PK 1:50
Kempny: ES 17:43 (B+), 0.51p60, -1.9cfrel, -1.0xgfrel / PP 0:02, 0.00p60 / PK 0:09

Orpik: ES 13:35 (C+), 0.66p60, -3.8cfrel, -5.5xgfrel / PP 0:00, 0.00p60 / PK 3:10
Djoos: ES 10:52 (C), 0.29p60, -4.2cfrel, -4.2xgfrel / PP 0:00, 0.00p60 / PK 0:00


Again, it's only the PP where he shines.
 
Last edited:
If Zaitsev plays more like rookie Zaits then last season's version, I think he can capably hold down the #4 spot. Or at least we have to hope that happens, because otherwise his contract becomes quite the boat anchor.

Did we ever sign that Ozighanov officially too?

I do think we will need to add a d-man though, and I'm not really sure who my top options would be.
Yeah, he's been signed to a one-year ELC.

So, he's likely in the mix to replace Roman Polak as the RHD on our third-pairing.
 
Back
Top