• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

I agree with both of you to a point. I agree with Montana that Nash would come here and become a much better player mostly because he would have more talent around him and he'd have a chance to play in the playoffs so he'd want to take it up a notch...With msun, i agree that it doesn't necessarily mean that just by playing with more talented players its a guarantee that you'll get better numbers(i do believe that Nash could do it). If you look at Kessel's numbers when playing with Savard, he had 36 goals but only 60 pts(he's mostly been 55-65) and Savard had close to 90 pts that season...so it really depends...Sometimes it works other times it doesnt. Is this year's Kessel better because of Lupul...at least partially? I believe so.


Young player plays with top flight linemates produces......continues to produce when young player reaches his prime, and elite linemates are removed.

To me that's not really all that surprising, nor do I really think it has a correlation to how a young player who played with shit linemates, might produce with better linemates while in his prime.

More than anything, I simply feel Nash would be able to reach the levels he already has[/].....but simply do so more consistently, via superior linemates.
 
tumblr_l3di1ag6Hk1qzybl5o1_500.gif


Maggie looks like she just read one of P84's posts.
 
IMO, if you can make a move for Carter and not give up Kadri at the same time they would make for a nice starting point as a line. Having a creative, playmaker as a winger makes a ton of sense for a scoring centreman like Carter.

As I mentioned before Grabo++ gets a deal done, but to be honest I'm not sure if that is a smart moves for the Leafs at this point in time. Let's say for instance something COULD get done at that level and you're looking at Grabovski, Aulie and Colborne for Carter (whether or not the Leafs-BJs would do it being irrelevant), then you would have a three-scoring-line system like:

Lupul - Bozak - Kessel
Kadri - Carter - MacArthur
Kulemin - Connolly - Armstrong

Personally, it doesn't really put the Leafs that much ahead in any way, especially viewed by the fact the Leafs 'need' is a 1C. So if you try to adjust the lines and slot Carter in at the position, maybe you could end up with:

Lupul - Carter - Kessel
Kulemin - Connolly - MacArthur
Kadri - Bozak - Armstrong

Again, does acquiring someone who might not be a bonafide 1C help us that much? In my opinion, not really although I do like the second line combos. I think in the end though with where we are right now, getting another legitimate threat as a scoring winger does us more than another centreman. While a 1C would lift our top line to the next level, having another scoring winger (like Kulemin should be if he could bury this year) would give us the secondary scoring we lack and take some of the pressure off the top line.

When Grabo's line is producing it's a whole different team and we seem so much more dangerous than when they struggle. And personally, if you can lock Grabo in to a 5x$5 deal, he is one of the better 2C options in the league.

Ideal scenario:

Lupul - Connolly - Kessel
Kadri - Carter - MacArthur
Kulemin - Grabo - Frattin

So, with that said... Bozak, Schenn and Colborne -for- Carter??? (you can pinch me now)
 
**** Jeff Carter and the TEN years left on his deal after this one. Not interested.

I'd take Carter in a heartbeat. He fits a need (Center), is signed to a good deal, has shown Chemistry with Lupul and would add size up front.

Doing it for Grabs+ would be a no brainer.
 
That contract will be an albatross on the team, long before it gets anywhere near the end.

F uck, it looks like an albatross NOW.
 
That contract will be an albatross on the team, long before it gets anywhere near the end.

F uck, it looks like an albatross NOW.

it isn't close to an albatross.

he's having a shit season but jeff carter's obviously better than a 25 goal, 45 point forward.

he's a 30+ goal 60-70 point forward... which is really about the same as rick nash has been the past two seasons, but for $2.3mn less per season.
 
That contract will be an albatross on the team, long before it gets anywhere near the end.

F uck, it looks like an albatross NOW.

I dunno, the contract lasts until he's 37, the last few years of which run 3 mil, 2 mil, 2mil. If he can be an impact player until he's mid thirties 5 mil/year cap hit isn't terrible.
 
I disagree with virtually everything you wrote, again, yes.....but Christ if this old song and dance doesn't get tiring.

When all ones left with, is repeating a stance they've laid out 3-4 times, to have you either ignore it, or twist what was said.

If you wish to continue reverse engineering my posts, to alter my point to fit the debate you'd like to have, feel free to continue doing it......

Wash, rinse, repeat.

yep, you're right.

providing evidence of the negligible impact that playing with 'better' players has had on multiple stars is ignoring, twisting, reverse engineering your posts and altering your point that playing with better players will probably lead to scoring increases for nash.

whatever you say.

anyways, you're entitled to think that.

i have never said this is absolute.. just in my opinion unlikely based on history and other tangible evidence... and if it does occur, probably more attributable to other factors (chemistry, system) than to playing with better players.
 
Your "evidence" isn't even applicable to my stance...but given your posts, I don't even think you've bothered to ascertain what my stance is.
 
you: rick nash will score more playing with better players

me: not everybody who plays with more players starts scoring more.. look at these players who didn't score more when they played with better players.. look at these players who scored more with lesser with players.

nope, not applicable at all.
 
yep, you're right.

providing evidence of the negligible impact that playing with 'better' players has had on multiple stars is ignoring, twisting, reverse engineering your posts and altering your point that playing with better players will probably lead to scoring increases for nash.

whatever you say.

anyways, you're entitled to think that.

i have never said this is absolute.. just in my opinion unlikely based on history and other tangible evidence... and if it does occur, probably more attributable to other factors (chemistry, system) than to playing with better players.

Now you believe in chemistry? You made fun of me when i argued using the same logic. For a guy who is usually all about talent, it's kind of hard to take you seriously on this point..like you're arguing even using arguments you don't truly believe in.
 
i don't really know what you're talking about.

i have never denied that some players simply have chemistry.

see...

naslund-morrison-bertuzzi
heatley-spezza-alfredsson

or more recently

macarthur-grabovski-kulemin

some guys jsut click, unexplainably.

and i have never denied that. ever.
 
I dunno, the contract lasts until he's 37, the last few years of which run 3 mil, 2 mil, 2mil. If he can be an impact player until he's mid thirties 5 mil/year cap hit isn't terrible.

The cap hit during those last years is still 5.27M. I wasn't saying that it's guaranteed to become an albatross contract, but locking in on a low-character guy like this for ten years isn't my cup of tea.

I do think he will probably rebound to some extent next year. But in the long run, I don't particularly like the player or the contract that much.
 
Back
Top