• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

And I don't get the hate for Brent. He really hasn't been that bad. I'd be happy if Hanson (or even Mitchy) can hold down Ziggy's spot centering the 4th line.
 
It's simple, axl.

He's an offensive void. I wouldn't care much if he was on the fourth line, but he's eating up tons of minutes with poor offensive strength. He doesn't forecheck particularly well, he's got poor playmaking skills and outside of his two tip ins, squat firepower.
 
This has been discussed a million times, but he's on the checking line. Scoring is not his job. He's been fine.

If a guy like Hanson can elevate his game and push Brent to the 4th line, I'd have no problem with that.
 
This has been discussed a million times, but he's on the checking line. Scoring is not his job. He's been fine.

If a guy like Hanson can elevate his game and push Brent to the 4th line, I'd have no problem with that.
I think that's the point people are trying to make. Our fourth line should be "the checking line". Our top two lines aren't good enough that we can afford throwing a 3rd line out there on a regular shift that has zero offensive firepower.
 
This has been discussed a million times, but he's on the checking line. Scoring is not his job. He's been fine.

it's patently untrue that a checking line shouldn't be counted on to produce.

the checking line need not produce offensive as consistently as the first or even the second line. but that doesn't excuse them from putting points up on the board. tertiary scoring is necessary for success, even on teams that aren't lacking skill at the top like the leafs are.

good checking lines are usually good checking lines because they are good at keeping the puck deep in the offensive zone, and capable of chipping in offense with some regularity.

the leafs checking line doesn't cycle well at all, and hasn't produced for poop.

when you factor in that another important aspect of a good checking line centre's game is faceoff ability, then take brent's embarrassing work on the draw into account, it becomes even more apparent that he is a huge black hole on this team.

nothing against him -- but he's gotta go.
 
Nobody said they don't have to chip in offensively, at all. And they have chipped in with a few goals this year. It's the top 2 lines that are not scoring much at all lately.

And I knew someone was going to bring up the faceoffs. Yes, that's a weakness in his game that he needs to get better at. But it is far from the most important part of his job.
 
it's patently untrue that a checking line shouldn't be counted on to produce.

the checking line need not produce offensive as consistently as the first or even the second line. but that doesn't excuse them from putting points up on the board. tertiary scoring is necessary for success, even on teams that aren't lacking skill at the top like the leafs are.

good checking lines are usually good checking lines because they are good at keeping the puck deep in the offensive zone, and capable of chipping in offense with some regularity.

the leafs checking line doesn't cycle well at all, and hasn't produced for poop.

when you factor in that another important aspect of a good checking line centre's game is faceoff ability, then take brent's embarrassing work on the draw into account, it becomes even more apparent that he is a huge black hole on this team.

nothing against him -- but he's gotta go.

This.
 
Kulemin-Hanson-Armstrong would be one helluva "checking line".

Physically beastly, fast, smart, skilled, and good on faceoffs to boot.
 
When you're a team where goals are hard to come by, having to toss Sjostrom and Brent over the boards every third shift when you're down by a goal doesn't really help matters.
 
I really can't believe there's so much defense of what the Leafs have done with their forwards.

Sjostrom, Brent, Zigomanis, Brown are all 4th line talents at best, and really AHL fodder.

Why anyone would ever defend building a 3rd line out of these guys is really bizarre to me.

These are all guys who would have trouble even cracking the 4th line of most teams in the league, and here we have people defending having 4 of them taking regular shifts.


These guys should be battling it out for 4th line duty for us, and that's it.
 
Sjostrom, Brent, Zigomanis, Brown are all 4th line talents at best, and really AHL fodder.

These are all guys who would have trouble even cracking the 4th line of most teams in the league, and here we have people defending having 4 of them taking regular shifts.
It's a bit silly to talk about these 4 players getting "regular" shifts, when 2 of them were on the 4th line (Zigo and Brown) all year, and one has already been sent to the AHL without protest. The other 2 are debatable whether they're 3rd or 4th line guys, I don't disagree that Sjostrom is a complete black hole offensively, although his work on the PK does serve a purpose and as Mbow pointed out recently, there's really no room for him on the 4th line at the moment.

My point is simply that people who are worried about goal scoring should worry less about blaming Tim Brent and Freddie Sjostrom, and more about blaming Kris Versteeg (1 goal), Tyler Bozak (1 goal), Nik Kulemin (1 goal) and Mikhail Grabovski (0 goals).

They are probably ultimately going to be 4th liners, but their supposed replacements Caputi and Hanson are already in the lineup.
 
One other thing about Brent, it looks like he has been working on his faceoffs because his FO% the last 3 games has been 57.1, 61.5 and 70.0%.
 
My point is simply that people who are worried about goal scoring should worry less about blaming Tim Brent and Freddie Sjostrom, and more about blaming Kris Versteeg (1 goal), Tyler Bozak (1 goal), Nik Kulemin (1 goal) and Mikhail Grabovski (0 goals).

There's people who saw it coming that this group of guys would go through dry spells and thought it'd be nice to have three scoring lines instead of two right off the bat.
 
I was in Brent's corner to start the season but recently I've been having second thoughts about keeping Brent on the team.

It's true the role of a checking line is to check ... but the thing is, Wilson isn't even confident enough to use Brent against the other team's top line anymore. The odd times he does, we get scored on, or we get trapped in our zone for a LONG time before we can get it out. These days Wilson's been using the Brent line vs the other team's 3rd or 4th line primarily.

If our checking line can't exactly check, and it's not physical, and it can't score, then why the heck do we keep this line???

If Brent is a very effective checker then maybe there's a point in keeping him on the team even though he has zero offensive talent ... but he's just an OK checker, and he is really subpar in all other areas.
 
Guys the only guy worth discussing to get rid of, is our circa 2010 versiion of Roger Neilson(captain video) Ron Wilson.

Unless we have Crosby, Malkin, Kessel, Brad Richards, Mike Richards etc... he is STILL going to play Mitchell, Brent and whomever in the last minute of play to protect a 1-0 loss.

And if Burke doesn't figure this out and FAST. He is going to go from Rock Star to feather and tar.

For the future of this franchise. GO SENATORS.
 
Back
Top