• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Let's be honest here: if this was anyone but a Red Wing player does MacArthur get suspended? Probably not. Shanahan needs to learn not to lead with his biases from his playing days IMO.
 
Let's be honest here: if this was anyone but a Red Wing player does MacArthur get suspended? Probably not. Shanahan needs to learn not to lead with his biases from his playing days IMO.
Yup. I'm also not surprised that a Leaf got whacked with a suspension at the first (flimsy) opportunity that came along, while the Grabovski headshot was pretty much the only head hit that went unpunished this pre-season. League bias on full display.
 
IMO you can criticize him for letting the Grabo hit go unpunished if you'd like but I don't see a bias overall. He's been pretty tough on headshots overall.
 
Not sure if this has been posted:

http://video.nhl.com/videocenter/console?id=125761

Shanahan with his explanation; what a load of crap.

I don't really understand this stand. He hit him in the head, should be punished! Personally I called for tougher management from the league for years (Colin Campbell was sheer incompetence), have been generally happy with Shanahan. I wouldn't even mind tougher punishments at all. If 5 games at a time doesn't stop these hits, then make it 10, make it 20, or find a way to punish the teams (like have them ice a team with one less skater during the suspension period). Hits to the head should not be allowed.


ps I always mention this, it's noteworthy that I have NEVER played hockey, tried skating ONCE. So there may be areas in the game that I may not see as someone who has simply watched hockey for years as opposed to play it.
 
Give me a break you guys are so biased. If its a Leaf getting hit like that you'd be calling for blood and don' compare it to the grabbo hit. They aren't the same and it's not even debatable.
 
Let's be honest here: if this was anyone but a Red Wing player does MacArthur get suspended? Probably not. Shanahan needs to learn not to lead with his biases from his playing days IMO.

Have you not been paying attention this preseason? Shanahan has been suspending just about any player who makes contact with the head. If he's so pro Red Wing then why did he throw the book at Brendan Smith with an 8 game (3+5) suspension? I agree the McCarthur hit was not that bad but don't cry bias cause that's not what's going on here.

Shanahan is being extreme in an effort to scare everyone out of doing this garbage. Players are getting hit hard with these suspensions and if they know they aren't going to get away with it anymore it's probably going to be reduced dramatically.
 
that's inevitable in hockey. concussions have happened because guys, like steckel, have followed through on those plays.

macarthur let up, which is why abdelkader didn't get hurt.

Yeah and that is why he got 2 games instead of 8. They are trying to get rid of that hit all together.

I agree it wasn't a dangerous hit, but its consistent with the new rule and what Shanahan has been doing this preseason.
 
the whole point of the crackdown on those sorts of hits is to underscore the fact that guys can line other players up but still have time to react if they're blindsiding them. it was physically impossible for macarthur to line up abdelkader in a way that would have been body-to-body, unless abdelkader braced for the impact and straightened up.

macarthur saw that he didn't, and let up on the hit. what macarthur did proves that guys like cooke could have eased up and not followed through on those big blindside hits. that's exactly what they're trying to deter. penalizing macarthur for it though just amounts to penalizing a guy for looking to make contact. that shouldn't be deterred.
 
It shouldn't be, but it is.

If the head is the principle point of contact, and the guy intentionally or recklessly goes through with the hit its not a legal hit anymore.
 
And MacArthur didn't go through with the hit. Which is why Abdelkader wasn't hurt. You can't go around penalizing guys who have internalized the new rules and are actively avoiding harming other player's heads as that sort of behavioural change is exactly what the new rules are designed to encourage.
 
Its not even worth having this debate. He clearly hit his head. Think what you want, but the hit to the head is the ONLY reason he was suspended.

If there was no hit to the head there would be no suspension under this rule. It is the "no hits to the head rule" no other type of hit is illegal under it.

Hell, even Mac acknowledges that he hit him in the head.
 
Back
Top