• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Schenn isn't just another Commodore, Komi or Volchenkov first and formost because he has puck skills. He can move the puck and make plays instead of just having to blindly throw it hard off the boards.

That is why he is so valuable.
 
he's either a #6/#7 dman with no upside and limited talent, or he's the main piece in a deal that brings us a star centre or winger.

make up your mind.

I am convinced that many GMs share your opinion of Schenn, and IMO its the wrong one.

It's just my opinion.

And for the record I don't think Schenn sucks, and I think he'd be higher on most every team's depth charts than he is on the Leafs' deep talented defense corps.
 
If the cost of getting Nash is a roster player not named Kessel,Lupul,Gardiner or Liles, a prospect, and a 1st and 2nd rounder, how the **** do you not want to make that deal?

I cant understand how so many of you here had a raging hard on for Richards and so many have a disdain for Nash. Nash is so what this team needs, big and powerful, scores goals.
Some of you are bitching about his point totals? Seriously? Playing in f*cking Columbus? With all the studs he has had to work with? Huselius? Umberger? Voracek? wow
Doesnt this remind anyone of the excuses tossed out for Sundin around these parts and his point total expectations?

Sundin put up 70-80 points every single season playing with relatively poor line-mates (at least for a competitive team's first line). Career 83 point seasonal average. Nash's career 82 game average is 67.

And he's a winger, so it's not like he's bringing the additional added value of a big centre that Sundin did.
 
I am convinced that many GMs share your opinion of Schenn, and IMO its the wrong one.

It's just my opinion.

And for the record I don't think Schenn sucks, and I think he'd be higher on most every team's depth charts than he is on the Leafs' deep talented defense corps.
It's amazing how deep our D corps is and how often our team doesn't play defense.
 
Playing for a last place team with shit for defense and shit for goaltending, and an organisation that has lacked any balls other than acquiring Jeff Carter, a player unwanted from his last team. Not that I condone this but it is easy to believe that playing for an organisation like that, a guy like Nash could feel less than enthusiastic about it.

Mats Sundin for the 1996-97 Leafs (23rd out of 26 teams): 41 goals 53 assists 94 points
Mats Sundin for the 1997-98 Leafs (20th out of 26 teams): 33 goals 41 assists 74 points
Mats Sundin for the 2007-08 Leafs (24th out of 30 teams): 32 goals 46 assists 78 points

Sundin had no problems performing offensively on sub-par teams. And if you're looking at the offensive stature of those teams they ranked 17th, 23rd, and 13th in scoring respectively. Nothing particularly impressive.
 
Mats Sundin for the 1996-97 Leafs (23rd out of 26 teams): 41 goals 53 assists 94 points
Mats Sundin for the 1997-98 Leafs (20th out of 26 teams): 33 goals 41 assists 74 points
Mats Sundin for the 2007-08 Leafs (24th out of 30 teams): 32 goals 46 assists 78 points

Sundin had no problems performing offensively on sub-par teams. And if you're looking at the offensive stature of those teams they ranked 17th, 23rd, and 13th in scoring respectively. Nothing particularly impressive.

I am aware of all that Jays, and I said a few posts after my initial one that I regretted mentioning Mats name. I wasnt trying to compared offensive outputs from each player, simply noting that a similar argument was used several times with Mats, that he didnt have the best linemates and thus his stats werent what they could have been.
 
I get what Zeke is saying....

Schenn is overrated in the same sense Nash is

I would agree with this and I'm arguably the biggest Schenn backer on the forum.

Zeke's right in pointing out that there are certain "heart and soul" guys that get overrated in the hockey world. The "lunch-pail" types that get venerated on every analyst panel while the pure skill guys that are significantly harder to find get trashed.

Ideally you need both to win but one of the two types of players is much easier to find than the other kind. Schenn's name value, recent top five draft status, performance at the World Juniors, and pedigree of making the league at a young age all provide him with more value than if he was a mid-career veteran type putting up the same performance.

It's the name value and potential that intrigues people about Schenn. He's good as things stand but there are still many that believe he can become a franchise type and I think he's just too limited that way.
 
I am aware of all that Jays, and I said a few posts after my initial one that I regretted mentioning Mats name. I wasnt trying to compared offensive outputs from each player, simply noting that a similar argument was used several times with Mats, that he didnt have the best linemates and thus his stats werent what they could have been.

My apologies, I should have read through the entire thread first rather than addressing each subsequent point as they came up during my reading.

Nash is a tremendous goal-scorer but you have to wonder about the production issues even sans a legitimate first-line centre. There have been guys out there that can produce no matter who they are paired with. And believe me, I am more than well-acquainted with Rick Nash's dominance at the Worlds and at the previous Olympics. He's always played incredibly well, aside from the 2006 Olympic disaster which was a team-wide implosion and not solely a 21 year-old Nash's fault, at the international level so it might lend some credence to the fact that he needs a serious opportunity to play with half-decent talent.

At the same time though, the inconsistent effort and lazy reputation has to be a serious red-flag for a Leafs team that is well-known around the league for providing a consistent effort each night.
 
No matter what happens, hopefully Nash will get dealt in the next few days. It'll suck if we have to listen to the media flog this story for another week.
 
And believe me, I am more than well-acquainted with Rick Nash's dominance at the Worlds and at the previous Olympics.....at the international level so it might lend some credence to the fact that he needs a serious opportunity to play with half-decent talent.

Might lend credence that he plays at that level under the spotlight as well. No bigger spotlight than Toronto.
 
I'm torn on Nash.

He's awesomely skilled, and gives us some much needed size up front.

At the same time, he's not really a super-elite player, but he gets paid like one.

I'd love to have him on the team, but I'm never gonna be happy about the pricetag (both contract and trade assets).
 
Super-elite is still one of the best names that this forum has come up with. Happy that it hasn't entered the popular vernacular quite yet.
 
Usually I am a believer GM's will take as long as they want and I wouldn't normally hold my breath on any 'soon to be traded' player.

In Nash's case though, I do believe he WILL get traded before the deadline, and in all likelihood he will get traded sooner than later.

Because Howsen isn't just trading Nash. He's doing a little reset on the team, and there will be other players who gets traded too.

If you want to unload say, Carter's contract, it'll be difficult in the summer. Right now though, is when teams are willing to overpay because they believe that's the player that'd put them over the top.

And, also keep in mind, it has been a disasterous season for the BJ's. After trading for Carter in the summer, they had their fans expecting they would take the next step and maybe win a round. Instead, they are selling the first overall pick now. I got 4 free tickets offered to me by CBJ because I went to their game back in November ... that tells you how bad things are in Columbus.

They want to make a statement before the season end to tell the fans "There's something to look forward to next season. We'll be a different team."

So I believe Nash will get traded, and sooner than later.
 
I'm torn on Nash.

He's awesomely skilled, and gives us some much needed size up front.

At the same time, he's not really a super-elite player, but he gets paid like one.

I'd love to have him on the team, but I'm never gonna be happy about the pricetag (both contract and trade assets).
We are yet to see what it takes in terms of trade assets. I don't think it'll be outrageous, if nothing else because of his contract and also the short list of teams he is willing to waive his NMC for.

I think at the end of ALL THIS though, what makes it tough for me to pull the trigger is the fact Nash signed such a long term contract on CBJ and then he pulled a no-show in the beginning of this season. When things weren't going well, Nash was part of the problem, not part of the solution. It makes me question his heart, his drive and his will to win. You can have all the skills in the world but will becomes a pretty big factor when playoff starts.
 
We are yet to see what it takes in terms of trade assets. I don't think it'll be outrageous, if nothing else because of his contract and also the short list of teams he is willing to waive his NMC for.

I think at the end of ALL THIS though, what makes it tough for me to pull the trigger is the fact Nash signed such a long term contract on CBJ and then he pulled a no-show in the beginning of this season. When things weren't going well, Nash was part of the problem, not part of the solution. It makes me question his heart, his drive and his will to win. You can have all the skills in the world but will becomes a pretty big factor when playoff starts.

Hey, i'm a pretty huge Kessel fan however i think that if we make the playoffs you'll notice that is easy to contain him as soon as you rough him up a bit. He thrives on open room play. Can i blame him for that? Well yes and no. Just because you're not that big, it doesn't mean you should shy away from the boards and not get your nose dirty...but in some ways i can understand it too. Anyways, the point is that Nash actually has the size and all the other tools to play well when games get physical and for those reasons i would like to get him here...at a reasonable price though. If it's giving up players like Gardiner, Lupul..no thanks.
 
its easy to make assumptions and project our own feelings on players but lets let the facts speak for themself...


Kessel Career in Playoffs
15 GP 9 G 6 A 15 PTS
 
Nash is still the better player regardless of who we have to give up.

Let it be Kadri though.. Colbourne/Nash has a nice ring to it.
 
It's interesting the common perception on a smallish player like Kessel is "Ohh they don't do anything in the playoff."

If all you have to do to shutdown Kessel is hit him, then I question how he manages multiple 30G seasons at such a young age.

You think it isn't known by now Kessel doesn't like playing rough??

All these little guys are swifty. I mean, I'm sure Gretzky didn't like to get hit either. The point is - you have to catch up to him to hit him.
 
Just say a big NO to Rick Nash. His days are gone. Great player, now a rich, spoiled, good player. Not worth the trouble. Get A GODDAMN GOALTENDER.
 
Back
Top