Artnes
Well-known member
Oooooh a half a season. That's a pretty ridiculous way of reaching YOUR conclusion.
I'm just showing market value for defensemen. Saying no to Nash because of Gardiner is based on pure and utter Leaf Goggles IMO. If you choose to have a different opinion, or think he's the next Niedermayer, then go for it. Please note that hockey players trajectories are not linear, as in they do not always go up or stay at the current level of production. Maybe Gardiner has limited offensive upside and will be a 40-45pt D-man in his prime, with great passing ability. This is not someone I would want to move, but to get a top line all star forward I'd do it in a heart beat.
We already traded away Neidermayer once. If we are lucky enough to have found another one I don't want to do that again and I am willing to take the chance that Gardiner turns into something special for us