The New Division

[corksens]

There are probably three defencemen I'd take on our team before I'd take one of yours.

Stop this.

Between this type of post and Jays suggesting Methot is "awful" we won't get anywhere.

 

[MyNameIsJonas]

Methot IMO is an ideal number 3 D, and maybe a 2.....far from awful

 

[JaysCyYoung]

lol

Daniel Briere was the only first rounder better than Phillips and he was on waivers before.

Chara and Briere were probably the only better players in that draft.

You're forgetting Kaberle too.

 

[MyNameIsJonas]

I think I owe some of you Sens fans an apology.

I sometimes take what KB says and assume you are all morons.

That's unfair

 

[JaysCyYoung]

There are probably three defencemen I'd take on our team before I'd take one of yours.

Are we comparing Binghamton to the Marlies now?

 

[MindzEye]

Cowen throws just as many hits

No, he doesn't.

and would beat Schenn to a bloody pulp.

Yeah, I can see why fighting Nokalainen, Chad Larose, & Ryan White would lead you to believe this.

 

[theREALkoreaboy]

Stop this.

Between this type of post and Jays suggesting Methot is "awful" we won't get anywhere.

Hot Karl is indisputably the best defenceman on either team. By far. I think methot is as valuable as phaneuf. He's much steadier and more reliable. And in terms of upside, I could see taking Cowen over phaneuf too. I'd agree that's only on potential though.

 

[MindzEye]

There are probably three defencemen I'd take on our team before I'd take one of yours.

Exactly what drugs are you on?

 

[MyNameIsJonas]

why does it matter if Cowen fights?

Does anyone want their "impact players" dropping the mitts?

Granted, if he is a bottom pairing goon, good on him.

 

[JaysCyYoung]

Cowen throws just as many hits and would beat Schenn to a bloody pulp.

Cowen is one of the softest players of his size in the NHL.

 

[MyNameIsJonas]

Hot Karl is indisputably the best defenceman on either team. By far. I think methot is as valuable as phaneuf. He's much steadier and more reliable. And in terms of upside, I could see taking Cowen over phaneuf too. I'd agree that's only on potential though.

This is worse then everything I have ever said combined together

 

[JaysCyYoung]

Stop this.

Between this type of post and Jays suggesting Methot is "awful" we won't get anywhere.

Huh? Where did I say he was awful? I said Cowen is awful.

 

[MindzEye]

Hot Karl is indisputably the best defenceman on either team.

Yes.

By far.

No

I think methot is as valuable as phaneuf.

1 potato

He's much steadier and more reliable.

2 potato

And in terms of upside, I could see taking Cowen over phaneuf too.

3 potato

I'd agree that's only on potential though.

4

 

[JaysCyYoung]

Hot Karl is indisputably the best defenceman on either team. By far. I think methot is as valuable as phaneuf. He's much steadier and more reliable. And in terms of upside, I could see taking Cowen over phaneuf too. I'd agree that's only on potential though.

I actually reported this post.

 

[theREALkoreaboy]

Lets see which one makes team Canada.

 

[JaysCyYoung]

Methot won't be anywhere near Team Canada. He has less chance of making the roster than I do.

 

[MyNameIsJonas]

Lets see which one makes team Canada.

Neither...but Phaneuf has an actual chance.

 

[zeke]

10 years of fighting over draft picks, 1998-2007:





C J.Spezza (30): 611gms, 228gls, 621pts, 18:41 (82gms, 31gls, 83pts)
C K.Wellwood (30): 489gms, 92gls, 235pts, 13:53 (82gms, 15gls, 39pts)

W M.Havlat (32): 700gms, 224gls, 557pts, 17:05 (82gms, 26gls, 65pts)
W B.Boyes (31): 606gms, 168gls, 407pts, 16:49 (82gms, 23gls, 55pts)

W A.Vermette (31): 670gms, 157gls, 350pts, 16:50 (82gms, 19gls, 43pts)
W A.Steen (29): 537gms, 123gls, 303pts, 17:31 (82gms, 19gls, 46pts)


C M.Fisher (33): 812gms, 206gls, 432pts, 17:21 (82gms, 21gls, 44pts)
C N.Antropov (33): 788gms, 193gls, 465pts, 15:49 (82gms, 20gls, 48pts)

W B.Laich (30): 566gms, 117gls, 282pts, 15:58 (82gms, 17gls, 41pts)
W N.Kulemin (27): 351gms, 75gls, 175pts, 15:53 (82gms, 18gls, 41pts)

W C.Greening (27): 153gms, 31gls, 69pts, 15:15 (82gms, 17gls, 37pts)
W A.Poni (33): 678gms, 139gls, 323pts, 14:22 (82gms, 17gls, 39pts)


C C.Kelly (33): 603gms, 100gls, 229pts, 14:56 (82gms, 14gls, 31pts)
C M.Stajan (30): 652gms, 109gls, 311pts, 15:23 (82gms, 14gls, 39pts)

W N.Foligno (26): 396gms, 67gls, 167pts, 14:11 (82gms, 14gls, 35pts)
W J.Tlusty (25): 276gms, 57gls, 112pts, 13:20 (82gms, 17gls, 33pts)

W P.Eaves (29): 414gms, 72gls, 141pts, 12:14 (82gms, 14gls, 28pts)
W V.Stalberg (27): 243gms, 52gls, 104pts, 13:06 (82gms, 18gls, 35pts)


C P.Regin (28): 178gms, 19gls, 55pts, 12:46 (82gms, 9gls, 25pts)
C J.Mitchell (29): 269gms, 35gls, 91pts, 13:48 (82gms, 11gls, 28pts)

W E.Condra (27): 155gms, 18gls, 48pts, 14:09 (82gms, 10gls, 25pts)
W M.Frattin (26): 82gms, 15gls, 28pts, 13:13 (82gms, 15gls, 28pts)

W C.Neil (34): 779gms, 94gls, 212pts, 11:21 (82gms, 10gls, 22pts)
W L.Komarov (27): 42gms, 4gls, 9pts, 13:56 (82gms, 8gls, 18pts)


C J.O'Brien (25): 63gms, 8gls, 12pts, 11:24 (82gms, 10gls, 16pts)
C ----------

W B.Bochenski (31): 156gms, 28gls, 68pts, 12:05 (82gms, 15gls, 36pts)
W ----------

W K.Daugavins (25): 91gms, 6gls, 15pts, 11:13 (82gms, 5gls, 14pts)
W R.Earl (28): 47gms, 6gls, 7pts, 8:58 (82gms, 11gls, 12pts)




D A.Meszaros (28): 533gms, 49gls, 202pts, 20:47 (82gms, 8gls, 31pts)
D I.White (29): 503gms, 45gls, 179pts, 20:52 (82gms, 7gls, 29pts)

D G.Zanon (33): 493gms, 12gls, 62pts, 19:51 (82gms, 2gls, 10pts)
D C.Gunnarsson (27): 224gms, 12gls, 69pts, 20;32 (82gms, 4gls, 25pts)


D T.Gleason (31): 599gms, 15gls, 127pts, 19:25 (82gms, 2gls, 17pts)
D C.Colaiacovo (31): 376gms, 30gls, 140pts, 17:54 (82gms, 7gls, 31pts)

D A.Volchenkov (31): 594gms, 19gls, 99pts, 18:45 (82gms, 3gls, 14pts)
D J.Harrison (31): 249gms, 16gls, 51pts, 17:37 (82gms, 5gls, 17pts)


D B.Lee (26): 209gms, 5gls, 36pts, 16:40 (82gms, 2gls, 14pts)
D A.Stralman (27): 313gms, 17gls, 99pts, 17:36 (82gms, 5gls, 26pts)

D E.Gryba (25): 33gms, 2gls, 6pts, 20:17 (82gms, 5gls, 15pts)
D K.Holzer (25): 24gms, 2gls, 3pts, 18:03 (82gms, 7gls, 10pts)


D C.Schubert (31): 315gms, 25gls, 72pts, 12:52 (82gms, 7gls, 19pts)
D K.Pilar (36): 90gms, 6gls, 30pts, 17:38 (82gms, 6gls, 27pts)

D -------
D B.Bell (30): 102gms, 7gls, 28pts, 15:47 (82gms, 6gls, 23pts)




G B.Elliott (28): 204gms, 98-71-21, 2.56gaa, 21so, .909wv%
G T.Rask (26): 138gms, 66-45-16, 2.15gaa, 16so, .927sv%

G R.Emery (31): 228gms, 126-63-19, 2.63gaa, 14so, .908sv%
G J.Reimer (25): 104gms, 53-32-14, 2.71gaa, 10so, .915sv%

G M.Prusek (37): 57gms, 31-12-4, 2.36gaa, 3so, .909sv%
G M.Tellqvist (34): 113gms, 45-41-10, 3.01gaa, 6so, .898sv%



OTT gets the star #1 C (and kept him), Leafs get the star #1 G (and traded him), and the rest is a whole lotta meh.




we'll see how the 5 years since then turn out.

so far OTT has the early edge there thanks to karlsson, at least.

 

[zeke]

Zeke, you're insane. I stopped reading after

phaneuf=hot Karl

That's the second stupidest thing said on this board all day after Schneider=hasek

Phaneuf = Karlsson

 

[MyNameIsJonas]

Zeke, has anyone ever thanked you for settling these arguments?