I was responding to Kahuna’s comment that we should just settle for whatever the linesmen call … not advocating for anything in particular.But that’s what it should try to fix. He was egregiously offsides. Not was he maybe 1cm early into the zone.
I think that what we’ve found is that the simple, common sense solution to an actual problem is not so simple in practice. We cut out wildly egregious errors but managed to introduce a razor’s edge application of rules that were written in broad brush strokes.