GGpX
Well-known member
Based on stats alone, John Tavares was better than those two at the same age.
The thing that made McDavid stick out when he was a teenager was his speed. While that seems to be pretty obvious, here's the thing: You'll often get prospects that are speedsters, but they either a) don't have the brain to go with their feet. It's almost like their body is going to fast for them to process the game or b) don't have the natural skill / body type to be much more than that.
McDavid was growing into a player with size, had the supreme skill of a can't miss prospect and he's probably the best skating hockey player I've ever seen? In a game that is growing faster and faster every day, he still looks way faster than everyone else. That's a very, very rare combination of traits that we'll be lucky to see one more time in our lifetimes.
The thing that made McDavid stick out when he was a teenager was his speed. While that seems to be pretty obvious, here's the thing: You'll often get prospects that are speedsters, but they either a) don't have the brain to go with their feet. It's almost like their body is going to fast for them to process the game or b) don't have the natural skill / body type to be much more than that.
McDavid was growing into a player with size, had the supreme skill of a can't miss prospect and he's probably the best skating hockey player I've ever seen? In a game that is growing faster and faster every day, he still looks way faster than everyone else. That's a very, very rare combination of traits that we'll be lucky to see one more time in our lifetimes.