• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

He's a -2 and was even a couple games ago. How exactly does he garner praise and make the All-Rookie Team as a -12 one year and then performs arguably better the next season according to some metrics and suddently "can't handle the NHL?"

Explain that to me.
 
Luke Schenn handled the NHL just fine in hsi rookie season.

he's having a sophomore setback, which is pretty typical.

Schenn will have a monster 2nd half. Mark my words.
 
He's 20 years old. Remarkably more patience seems to be shown to just about any other young player the Leafs have had recently.
 
Coming from the guy who's written off more homegrown leaf kids than any other poster.
 
Coming from the guy who's written off more homegrown leaf kids than any other poster.

Coming from the guy who thinks they all have top-line upside, of course. And the guy who's been on Schenn since day one, while sucking the dick of mediocrities like Mitchy for no reason at all.
 
Agreed.

Just like Colin Wilson, Cody Hodgson, Mikeal Boedker.

Lots of teams would love to have those guys.

Difference is Schenn has shown he can handle it big time.



Not all that impressed with any of these guys either. One can skate, none of the three has an above average NHL shot. They suck as well. It is what the OHL and WHL do, they create hack and chop players. The player has to go OUTSIDE the junior box, to become anything.
 
It would be suicide for Atlanta to deal Kovy while the team is in playoff contention. If he doesn't sign an extension with Atlanta, you'll see a bidding war to get his signing rights (ala Bouwmeester).
 
Coming from the guy who thinks they all have top-line upside, of course. And the guy who's been on Schenn since day one, while sucking the dick of mediocrities like Mitchy for no reason at all.

I think what you mean is "Coming from the guy who was RIGHT about Schenn and Mitchy from day one".

You know, the guy that said Schenn wasn't worth a top-5 pick and had 2nd pair Phillips/Komisarek upside.

And the guy who picked an obscure 5th round pick like Mitchell who nobody talked about and said he had very real NHL potential when nobody else did.
 
I think what you mean is "Coming from the guy who was RIGHT about Schenn and Mitchy from day one".

You know, the guy that said Schenn wasn't worth a top-5 pick and had 2nd pair Phillips/Komisarek upside.

And the guy who picked an obscure 5th round pick like Mitchell who nobody talked about and said he had very real NHL potential when nobody else did.

Let's no get too arrogant here, zeke. Mitchell was a classic case of a player picked from one of the singularly best developmental pipelines in the CHL (Plymouth had three players alone discussed in "Future Greats and Heartbreaks" that have become NHL contributors from one team) and didn't have classically intriguing upside but was likely to make the NHL based purely on his ability to perform a wide variety of roles well. And it's no coincidence that Mitchell started sucking when he began to deviate away from his defensive play, energy, and forechecking abilities and started to try to play like Sidney Crosby. He was a projectable prospect who always had a reasonable shot at making it. It's not like you were the only one claiming this. I also remember commenting on him and the Williams pick years ago.
 
Let's no get too arrogant here, zeke. Mitchell was a classic case of a player picked from one of the singularly best developmental pipelines in the CHL (Plymouth had three players alone discussed in "Future Greats and Heartbreaks" that have become NHL contributors from one team) and didn't have classically intriguing upside but was likely to make the NHL based purely on his ability to perform a wide variety of roles well. And it's no coincidence that Mitchell started sucking when he began to deviate away from his defensive play, energy, and forechecking abilities and started to try to play like Sidney Crosby. He was a projectable prospect who always had a reasonable shot at making it. It's not like you were the only one claiming this. I also remember commenting on him and the Williams pick years ago.

You know shit about junior, junior.
 
Back
Top